Judging the Olympics: The High and Lows of “The Games”
The Olympics in Beijing has been a great disappointment. No one has collapsed into a coughing fit from the air pollution — all but a certainty from the reports leading up to the opening of what are so quaintly termed “the games.” The American cyclists who arrived in the Beijing Airport wearing face masks seemed to have made it through the opening ceremonies without contracting “black lung” or suffering a terminal case of “ring around the collar.” I feel I have been let down yet again by the press.
Not all has gone well, however. In what no one seems to have noticed as a protest gesture that dwarfs Carlos and Smith’s now legendary salute, the women’s beach volleyball venue was the scene of a protest for the ages. The American, Misty May-Treanor bent over with her back to President Bush.
This certainly symbolically summed up what the American people have been doing for the past seven years of the Bush administration. Oddly, there was no comment from the press, no IOC or USOC officials rushed in to put Misty on a plane out of Beijing in disgrace. You can bet that Avery Brundidge would have understood this gesture, and punishment would have been swift and harsh.
Indeed, little Bobby Costas seemed to find the entire episode amusing. Context apparently is everything.
The nightly Michael Phelps show was quite impressive and nearly devoid of any controversy. Phelps’ display in the pool was great television, great sport, and just the sort of thing that brings people to their television sets in big numbers. It will also mean big money for Phelps. He should have been designated an NBC vice-president for programming, rather than being crowned with the understated title of “greatest athlete of all-time.”
While Phelps was dominating prime time, NBC also offered a seemingly endless parade of gymnastics events. The men’s and women’s competitions both provided high quality performances from the U.S. and Chinese participants, and perhaps also from many others nations not deemed worthy of prime time by NBC. In fairness to NBC, they did manage to work in a stray Russian or Romanian now and again.
The great drama of the gymnastics venue was the U.S. v. China. Here we had what we have come to expect from the American television version of the Olympics. The U.S. commentators were in good form whining about the scoring of the judges who somehow never scored the U.S. gymnasts high enough, and simultaneously managed to score the Chinese gymnasts higher than they deserved.
Then there was the great “age controversy” in the pixie division of the gymnastics competition. As the Chinese women began to collect their medals, the American reporters and commentators went into action on the age issue. The charge was that at least one Chinese woman was 13 years old, not the required 16. There were suggestions of fraud by the Chinese authorities issuing false documents for these young women. There was one report that seemed to offer some proof that one competitor was only 13. And if you looked at them, well, certainly many did not look 16.
One of the things that puzzled me about the age issue was that when I was 16 it was a humiliation to be beaten by some little kid in anything. Certainly to have your lunch handed you by a 13 year old would not be something you would want to advertise to your peers. Yet here were the Americans complain about being beaten by a child.
Adding to the objectivity of this reporting, NBC trotted out that highly reliable man of measured and cool judgment, Bela Karolyi. The former Romanian gymnastics coach, who built his career on the back of Nadia Comaneci, hyperventilated on camera over the obvious cheating being done by the Chinese. That Karolyi, exposed as a serial child abuser in Joan Ryan’s “Little Girls in Pretty Boxes,” should be anywhere near NBC’s gymnastics reporting brings shame on this once distinguished television network.
In the 1990s, it was the Chinese swimmers who were winning the medals that belonged to the United States. That led to the repeated cries of doping by the American competitors and television commentators. That the swimmers were passing drug tests at the Olympic Games didn’t matter, everyone knew they were cheating. Indeed many were, although that does not negate that fact that American losses in most any sport too often provokes charges of cheating, rather than respecting the achievements of athletes from other nations.
Before that it was the Eastern Bloc using men in women’s competitions, using professionals in an amateur competition, or juicing up their athletes in some way or another. But then when American athletes fail, as Roseanne Roseannadanna once astutely observed, “It’s always something.”
Despite their over-the-top reporting and analysis, their nationalist bias, and the mind-bending and confusing time warps, NBC has still managed to bring more of the games to the American viewing public, if you are willing to look for them in their various obscure cable and satellite locations. The quality of the camera work, combined with the spectacular high-definition format, put the viewer in the stadium — and often in the event — in ways never before experienced.
There has been some very good reporting, even by those who are in New York watching the games on huge HD screens. Of those announcers I have seen and heard, I especially like the work of Al Trautwig on gymnastics, excluding the color commentators, Mike Breen, Doug Collins and Ann Meyers on basketball, and most of those at the track and field venue, both male and female. The camera work at this venue has also been spectacular.
So enjoy the remainder of the games despite the underage competitors and the unprofessional commentators, always remembering while you watch this international spectacle that it’s the competition and the individual effort that matters most. Unless you’re looking for endorsements.












August 22, 2008 at 1:18 pm
I like how you brought up the Chinese swimmers as an example of U.S. whining, and then point out that the “whining” was warranted. I wonder if anyone would have investigated them to the point of guilt if the U.S. HADN’T brought it up. If you’re expected to win something, and a darkhorse suddenly makes an unexpected, inexplicable run…it always begs questions. Maybe it’s because the IOC has consistently done a poor job of policing the Olympics that individual countries have to do it for them. And that’s our job as a superpower, is it not? Make sure everyone stays in line? It’s too bad that no one paid attention to “Age Gate” when it was brought up BEFORE the Olympics, as opposed to during the medal ceremony as you assert. I wonder what label the U.S. would have gotten then.
August 22, 2008 at 1:47 pm
good article, good personality! It’s reget that ther are not so many american like you. It’s glad that American can go on and go on with the American who are not same as you.
cheers!
August 22, 2008 at 2:47 pm
LOL. If I read this correctly you\’re suggesting that it is poor sportsmanship to point out the winner of an event became so by breaking the rules… even when it is proven true.
Nice to see you are so level headed. Who needs a level playing field? Let\’s just ignore it when countries systematically break rules to favor their own athletes. That\\\’s *real* sportsmanship. (?!)
I have no beef with the Chinese girls, they\\\’d be in a work camp if they did anything to upset their government. I DO have a problem with the IOC and FIG not having the balls to enforce the same rules across the board regardless of why.
The Chinese went to great lengths to hide prior age certs for athletes who magically aged rapidly between previously published official reports containing their birthdays and the issuance of the passports the FIG accepted without question.
If that doesn\\\’t bother you, you\’re wastin time reporting on sports… you have a future covering presidential politics.